BY Ian Dunn | July 28 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS     print icon print

13-CHARLIE-GARD-FIGHT

Questions for the media and state over Charlie Gard case

Barring a miracle, by the time you read this, Charlie Gard will be dead.

Barring a miracle, by the time you read this, Charlie Gard will be dead. His parents’ decision to drop their court case, pushing for the right to take him for experimental treatment in America mean that people around the world will mourn this child this weekend. It is a case of profound complexity, but his parents suffering has a shattering simplicity. To lose a child is a tragedy, to do so in such an agonising, hope-bleeding way is unbearable.

On the one hand it is a case where certainty is impossible. Medical advancements have made it increasingly difficult to tell when hope is gone. Without medical expertise, without first-hand knowledge, it is almost impossible to know when that point has been reached. Indeed, even with those things it is not always clear.

But however thin the hope, his parents had the right to try and grasp it. They believe that if they’d been allowed to try and take Charlie for experimental treatments in America he would be alive now. They may be wrong, but they had the right to try. The fact they were denied that is what has outraged so many. As we have seen here in Scotland with the named person legislation, many, many parents feel that the state priorities are different from their own—and they fear running afoul of them.

The media firestorm around the case in the last few weeks should also concern us. The fire hose attention on a young couple under huge strain, and the endless proliferation of self-righteous certainties are not new, but they seem particularly trite in this case.

Further, as is so often with the British press, the coverage of the Gard’s carried a sneering, snobbish undertone. If the Gard’s had been more middle-class, had sharper elbows, been more like the doctors who decided the fate of their sons, they may well have been allowed to take their son to America. The wealth of the parents determines the fate of the child to still unfathomable degrees.

But all that is in the past. Today all we can do is pray for this poor child and his parents. And hope that one day, they will be reunited in Heaven.

 

Leave a Reply

latest opinions

Teachers should be free to share Catholic theology

January 18th, 2019 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

Pauline Gallagher, an RE teacher in Glasgow Archdiocese, argues that...


Faith must not be confined to the RE department

January 18th, 2019 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

Addressing the ‘elephant in the room,’ Fr Michael Kane says...


Cromwell ordered priests to be clubbed to death and massacred the Irish—his statue has no place at Westminster

January 18th, 2019 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

Labour MP Stephen Pound writes following a heated debate surrounding...


A pro-immigration argument for Brexit

January 18th, 2019 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

Leaving the EU is good for trade, immigration and the...



Social media

Latest edition

P1-JAN-18-2019

exclusively in the paper

 

  • Disused seminary is ‘albatross around our neck,’ says Church
  • Bishop calls on Catholics to visit the Holy Land to support Christian communities
  • Medals celebrate volunteers who built up young church
  • The Reformation and the judging of the poor
  • God has a vocations plan for everyone, Peter Diamond finds

Previous editions

Previous editions of the Scottish Catholic Observer newspaper are only available to subscribed Members. To download previous editions of the paper, please subscribe.

note: registered members only.

Read the SCO