October 7 2011 | comments icon 1 COMMENT     print icon print

5-PETER-KEARNEY

Bigotry report findings questioned

— Church and politicians query claims that sectarianism is a ‘myth’ in modern day Scotland

A new academic report that claims sectarianism and religious bigotry are a ‘myth’ in modern-day Scotland has been questioned by the Catholic Church and politicians.

Gillian Raab, an emeritus professor of applied statistics at Edinburgh’s Napier University, claimed that inter-marrying between young Catholics and Protestants had eroded the ‘social distance between sectarian groups.’

Her conclusions were based on an analysis of 111,000 couples from the 2001 Scotland census, the first to include questions about religious affiliation.

However, a Church spokesman suggested the work’s conclusion made no sense, an anti-sectarian campaigner said her claims were a ‘huge mistake,’ while a Labour politician has questioned whether an academic based in Edinburgh was in the right position to address a problem which he believed largely occurs on Scotland’s west coast.

Not a myth

Ms Raab’s thesis, published in the scientific journal, Ethnic and Racial Studies, concluded: “Rather than policies to reduce sectarianism, what may be needed to promote future harmony are initiatives to tackle the promotion of the myth of sectarianism and the reality of football-related violence.”

Peter Kearney (above right), the director of the Catholic Church’s Media Office, questioned how Gillian Raab arrived at her conclusion.

“You can say that people in Scotland are generally less religious and there are more marriages between Catholics and Protestant, these are both things which are true,” he said. “But I don’t know how you get from there to the conclusion that sectarianism is a myth when it clearly isn’t.”

Crimes

Dave Scott, campaign director at anti-sectarian charity Nil By Mouth, said that, since 2003, almost 2500 people have been convicted of sectarian offences across Scotland.

A former police officer and Rangers supporter was this week found guilty of singing sectarian songs at Ibrox, fined £1000 and banned him from attending football matches for five years.

While a probationary officer with Strathclyde Police, Jamie Hetherington was detained during the Rangers versus Aberdeen game in April last year. Sheriff Lindsay Woods told the 23-year-old at Glasgow Sheriff Court, that he had ‘brought shame’ on the force.

Opposition view

Tom Harris, who is campaigning to be Labour’s Scottish leader, has urged MSPs to vote down the SNP Government’s Offensive Behaviour at Football and Threatening Communications Bill, but said few on the west coast would think sectarianism was a myth.

“I feel quite strongly that anyone living in Glasgow is not going to believe that sectarianism is a myth “ Mr Harris said. “It makes sense that generationally those traditional divides are less than they were, because of course there are inter-marriages and fewer people going to church, but here in Glasgow and the west it is anything but a myth. I wish it was. There is a danger that someone could read this research and use it as an excuse to be complacent about the need to tackle sectarianism. Ms Raab obviously doesn’t believe it is the problem it is, because she lives on the east coast of Scotland. It is dangerous to call sectarianism a myth.”

First minister

Last week, First Minister Alex Salmond said sectarianism was threatening the future of Scottish football and called for legislation to address it.

“Sectarianism is not a myth,” a Scottish Government spokesman said. “Sectarianism and other offensive behaviour will not be tolerated in modern Scotland. As surveys show, more than 90 per cent of Scots support stronger action being taken to tackle sectarianism and offensive behaviour associated with football.”

The Justice Committee report on the Offensive Behaviour in Football and Threatening Communications Bill was due to be published this week.

[email protected]

Comments - One Response

  1. Martin says:

    You seem to be confusing football rivalry with sectarianism, as so many of Scotland “ruling classes” and vested interests do. If you actually live in our communities, you would realise we are more offended by the fact that people will die as a result of fuel poverty, than some idiot singing songs.

    What are you doing to address the real issues facing the most vulnerable members of our community, some of whom may die this winter as result of money grabbing fuel companies profiteering ?

    What are you doing to address the very real issues of homelessness facing many of the poorest families in our community as a result of the Goverenments cuts in Housing Benefits ?

    These are the real issues that offend and affect our communities, if not our spiritual and political leaders.

Leave a Reply

latest news

Vandals target Carfin Grotto’s Glass Chapel

April 27th, 2012 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

The Glass Chapel at Carfin Grotto in Motherwell Diocese was...


Scots lead the way for HCPT Trust

April 27th, 2012 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

— Scotland honoured in its 40th anniversary year with leading role...


US nuns shocked by Vatican report

April 27th, 2012 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

— Leadership Conference of Women Religious is reprimanded by Church over...


Pitlochry priest’s prompt action prevents theft

April 26th, 2012 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

A quick-thinking priest in Pitlochry trapped a suspected thief in...




Social media

Latest edition

PAGE-1-APRIL-27-2012

exclusively in the paper

  • Fr Graham Turner, who died one week after his ordination on Easter Monday, is to rest in Edinburgh
  • Fr Andrew McKenzie and Scots College seminarian Nick Welsh offer insight and inspiration ahead of the World Day of Prayer for vocations.
  • Schonenstatt Centre hosts special Pilgrim Mother Shrine rally.
  • As the countdown to the Olympics goes down to double figures, Lawrence Sum of the Scottish Bible Society writes on getting fit spiritually

Previous editions

Previous editions of the Scottish Catholic Observer newspaper are only available to subscribed Members. To download previous editions of the paper, please subscribe.

note: registered members only.

Read the SCO