BY Ian Dunn | March 1 2013 | comments icon 13 COMMENTS     print icon print


Cardinal O’Brien steps down

Pope Benedict XVI accepted resignation of His Eminence before he himself left office

Pope Benedict XVI accepted the resignation of Cardinal Keith O’Brien as Archbishop of St Andrews and Edinburgh on Monday, effective immediately.

Cardinal O’Brien had sent his resignation to the Vatican last year, due to age and health concerns, ahead of the mandatory retirement age of 75 that he reaches on March 17. The cardinal remains a cardinal elector until his 80th birthday but he is no longer travelling to the Vatican to take part in the conclave to elect the next Pope after Pope Benedict stepped down yesterday.

Last weekend it emerged that three priests and a former member of the clergy had made allegations of ‘inappropriate conduct’ against the cardinal to Nuncio Archbishop Antonio Mennini, and that the Vatican was investigating their claims. Cardinal O’Brien is contesting the allegations and seeking legal advice.

In a dignified statement on his resignation, Cardinal O’Brien demonstrated his continued pastoral care for the Church by deciding to not attend the conclave to avoid detracting attention from its business.

“I do not wish media attention in Rome to be focused on me—but rather on Pope Benedict XVI and on his successor,” he said. “I will pray with them and for them that, enlightened by the Holy Spirit, they will make the correct choice for the future good of the Church.”

The cardinal said that, due to his ‘indifferent health,’ he had tendered his resignation to the Pope last year, and that the Pope had provisionally accepted it. The Holy Father, who cleared urgent business prior to stepping down himself, decided that the resignation would take effect immediately and he would appoint an apostolic administrator for St Andrews and Edinburgh Archdiocese until a successor was found.

Cardinal O’Brien said he was grateful for any opportunities to do good he’d had as archbishop and said sorry to anyone he had hurt.

“Looking back over my years of ministry: For any good I have been able to do, I thank God,” he said. “For any failures, I apologise to all whom I have offended. I have valued the opportunity of serving the people of Scotland and overseas in various ways since becoming a priest.”

Auxiliary Bishop Stephen Robson took his place at a Mass of Thanksgiving for Pope Benedict at St Mary’s Cathedral on Sunday, with ‘a heavy heart.

First Minster Alex Salmond was among the first people to pay tribute to the departing archbishop and said his lifetime of good works should not be overlooked.

“I hear the news of Cardinal O’Brien’s resignation with the greatest sadness,” he said. “In all of my dealings with the cardinal, he has been a considerate and thoughtful leader of the Catholic Church in Scotland, stalwart in his Faith but constructive in his approach.

“It would be a great pity if a lifetime of positive work was lost from comment in the circumstances of his resignation.”

Professor John Haldane—professor of philosophy at St Andrews University, adviser to the Pontifical Council for Culture, and one of Scotland’s most respected Catholic academics—said he believed the cardinal had made the right choice to resign immediately.

“I think in these circumstances, to go to Rome under the cloud of these allegations—even though they, at this stage, simply remain that—would not be helpful for him, it would attract attention,” he said.

Many Catholics have spoken in defence of Cardinal O’Brien after the allegations, and have called on his accusers to make their identities known.

This sentiment was articulated by prominent Catholic businessman Sir Tom Farmer, a good friend of Cardinal O’Brien’s, who said he was ‘very surprised’ at the news and that the cardinal is ‘a very good man.’

“No specific charges have been made beyond ‘inappropriate conduct’ and it is unfair and unacceptable that such a statement has been made by people who are being allowed to hide behind a cloud,” he said.

Peter Kearney, spokesman for Scotland’s bishops, said:  “The faith of Catholics… is a personal faith in God. It will not be destroyed by events and controversies or the individual failings of anyone.”


–        This story was reported in full in the March 1 print edition of the SCO.





Comments - 13 Responses

  1. Jackie Gallagher says:

    Strangest story I have ever heard. Methinks His Eminence Cardinal Keith Patrick O’Brien is the subject of a stitch up. I’ve never actually felt so sad or disillusioned with my faith as I do now. He is innocent until proven otherwise and deserves our respect for the fantastic work he has done over the years.

  2. david says:

    Jackie – do not feel disillusioned with your faith. These are certainly difficult times, but its our faith that will see us through this!

  3. Kenny Purdie says:

    I totally agree Jackie Gallagher. This is a lose, lose situation no matter what the truth is. Its a very hard time for lay Catholics “out in the world”, but I think the majority of our hardworking Priests know that and are praying for us.

  4. A Murchie says:

    I know these allegations are unproven at present, but what a mess either way the church seems to be in. With the current horrific history of proven widespread paedophilia within elements of Catholic clergy and then these accusations of the inability to live within the vows of celibacy within the hierarchy here and in Rome, I as a divorced Catholic who has suffered great personal guilt and some family opposition due to my ‘sinning’ feel particularly let down by the Church hierarchy who obviously now seem to have different rules for the lay people and for themselves.

  5. Simon says:

    Cardinal O’Brien has tonight admitted homosexual transgressions.

  6. Jim Monan says:

    Why have you not updated your website to reflect that O’Brien has now admitted that these allegations of misconduct are true?

  7. Barb Brown says:

    So I see that my last comment was moderated off …..I guess you are not open to knowing how non-Catholics feel and what questions we might have. Honestly how can you keep burying your heads in the sand? At what point are one’s beliefs and practices so contrary to that of Rome that one can no longer call themselves Catholic?

  8. liz says:

    yes he did wrong and admitted it,and yes things shouldnt be hidden but neither should the so called men of god who call themselves priests who are hiding behind each other, why wait until now to make your claims? is there someone egging them on for their own gain?
    its like a witch hunt.would you go to them with a problem? not likely.

  9. Daniel Martin says:

    Although I do not currently practice my wife continues to attend mass weekly and the church does play a role in my life. I am therefore keen to comment. I believe the church to be in real trouble – not something I like to say or hear but nonetheless true. Repeated scandals of a sexual and corrupt nature are bound to rock people’s faith – as they did mine. Alongside this the increasingly incompatible adherence to outdated and inevitably (in the future) illegal doctrines on homosexuality. Although tradition and reference to fundematal principles should be observed I feel that modernisation is essential to protect the church for those that it provides so much spiritual help and support for. I would be keen for pople’s thoughts on this if possible.

Leave a Reply

previous lead stories

MSP accuses government of ‘treating Catholic and Irish community with contempt’

June 15th, 2018 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

Labour’s James Kelly hits out over make-up of working group...

Sturgeon: Catholic schools shaped modern Scotland

June 8th, 2018 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

First Minister praises Catholic ethos in Education Act centenary lecture...

Parishes and Catholic groups can provide solutions to loneliness, Church tells government

June 1st, 2018 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

Submission to consultation on growing problem highlights the value of...

Scots ‘flooding Heaven with prayers’ ahead of Irish vote

May 25th, 2018 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

Polls predict abortion will be introduced in Ireland, but pro-lifers...

Social media

Latest edition


exclusively in the paper

  • Four page Caritas Feature
  • Church Calls on Labour MSP to prove abortion comments
  • Hugh Dougherty on Ireland’s repeal vote
  • Aggressive Secularism a threat to democracy, Bishop says.

Previous editions

Previous editions of the Scottish Catholic Observer newspaper are only available to subscribed Members. To download previous editions of the paper, please subscribe.

note: registered members only.

Read the SCO