April 12 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS     print icon print


Outrage culture is too quick to condemn and denounce

Amid the ever-changing winds of an unmoored society, the Church offers concrete moral direction, by Fr Michael Kane

This weekend marks the beginning of Holy Week with the celebration of Palm Sunday.

It also signals the start of a very busy period around our parish. The statues have already been covered with purple cloth, the altars have been prepared, and the final preparations are being made for the solemn Triduum liturgies.

Aside from the practical considerations there is a stark key change in tone of the liturgy.

The reserved mood of Lent is briefly broken by the joy of Palm Sunday, only to be replaced by the shadow of the Cross, and the emerging glory of the empty tomb.

The liturgies are sensory and dramatic, and full of extremes.


A high point

One of the most striking elements of Holy Week is the change of tone in such a short space of time.

Palm Sunday is a high point in the Lord’s public ministry.

The people are astonished at His powerful preaching and the gracious words that come from His mouth. They are overwhelmed by His miracles and healings and want to forcibly make Him their King.

The chants of ‘Hosanna’ ring out as a great sign of his favour among men. He is very much the man of the moment.

How quickly things can change. How effortlessly the cries of ‘Hosanna’ are replaced by the death sentence of ‘Crucify Him!’

How quickly the people turn on Jesus when His Gospel begins to challenge them.

More than once I have wondered how it was that Jesus’ fate changed so suddenly.


Evident today

Why would the crowds turn against Him at a whim? Does it highlight a deep flaw in our human nature which is hungry to condemn?

It seems to me that 2,000 years later that flaw is as evident as ever. Human nature remains as fickle and changeable as in the Lord’s time.

Take for example the Western approach to Christian values. Core beliefs that were once cherished and celebrated can all of a sudden lose their appeal and be labelled as out of date, or even dangerous.

The Gospel and the Church are subject to the changeable face of society and the consequences of a fickle human nature.

Where once our Christian values were met with approval and respect, just like Jesus in the Gospel, those same values dare not be mentioned in some quarters today.


Bedrock of society

Take for example the constant and unwavering esteem we have for traditional marriage and natural family life, as the bedrock of society.

This and many other core beliefs concerning life and human dignity are now treated in some quarters with utter contempt, as detestable relics from another generation.

When we look at contemporary culture we tend to thrive on extremes. We intensely like or intensely hate, and the pendulum never stops.

Things that are relevant and warmly received today might be relegated to the dustbins of history tomorrow.


Today’s heroes, tomorrow’s villains

Even in our own personal relationships it only takes a word or a heated exchange and we swing with great gusto in the opposite direction.

Human life is full of these sorts of swings. Today’s hero football manager might be tomorrow’s villain. Today’s saviour politicians are condemned as tomorrow’s traitors.

One wrong step and the cries of the crowd emerge once again to condemn and denounce.

The pendulum of change keeps on swinging. People move further apart, to the extent that isolationism, borne out of extremes, becomes the order of the day.

How do we counteract this tendency within us? How do we avoid living on the extremes? It seems to me that culture must change.


Culture of criticism

Only last week Jesus warned against a culture of condemnation in the Gospel of the adulterous women.

Only when we recognise the dignity of other people can we temper our tendency to denounce.

Only when we understand that sin and error does not take away that dignity will we begin to see others with new eyes.

In this Holy Week of intense extremes: of light and darkness, Faith and doubt, death and resurrection, may we try to live our lives guided by the unchanging and glorious wisdom of Jesus.


Leave a Reply

latest opinions

Pope’s visit reminds us to take inspiration from the martyrs of Japan

November 29th, 2019 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

I wasn’t much interested in the Pope’s visit to Japan,...

The everyday life of a Catholic school chaplain revealed

November 22nd, 2019 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

It surprises so many people that the mission of a...

Be ready to stand up for Catholic education as secular agendas gather pace

November 22nd, 2019 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

In our increasingly secular society, Catholic schools and their ethos,...

Social media

Latest edition


exclusively in the paper

  • Falkirk church prepares soup for 8,000 during gas outage
  • Golden celebration of community at St Margaret’s
  • Aberdeen Knights mark centenary with four-figure gift
  • Leadership is about service, Jesuit reminds parliament
  • Dumfries church daubed with graffiti twice in the same week

Previous editions

Previous editions of the Scottish Catholic Observer newspaper are only available to subscribed Members. To download previous editions of the paper, please subscribe.

note: registered members only.

Read the SCO