BY Ian Dunn | February 29 | comments icon 2 COMMENTS     print icon print

HUMAN-FETUS

Catholic midwives cannot exercise conscience on abortion

Breaking News: Court of Session in Edinburgh rules that Greater Glasgow and Clyde Health Board is not infringing on midwives' human rights by not allowing them to conscientiously object to a supervisory role. Full report in this week's SCO

The Court of Session in Edinburgh has ruled that midwives can be forced to supervise the carrying out of abortions.

Judge Lady Smith today rejected the case brought by Catholic midwives Mary Doogan, 57, and Concepta Wood, 51, who hold supervisory positions in the labour ward of Glasgow’s Southern General Hospital. The women claimed that being made to oversee staff involved in abortions was a breach of their human rights.

In her ruling, Lady Smith said the 1967 Abortion Act allowed only qualified conscientious objection, and that the provisions of the European Convention on Human Rights in relation to freedom of conscience and religion were not absolute.

Miss Doogan said she and Mrs Wood were ‘very disappointed’ with the verdict, which she said would have ‘very grave consequences for anyone of conscience who wishes to choose midwifery as a career.’

In her judgement, Lady Smith said the two midwives were ‘protected from having any direct involvement with the procedure to which they object.’

“Nothing they have to do as part of their duties terminates a woman’s pregnancy,” she said. “They are sufficiently removed from direct involvement as, it seems to me, to afford appropriate respect for and accommodation of their beliefs.”

John Deighan, the Scottish bishops’ parliamentary officer, said the judgement ‘should be very concerning to all of society.’

“We will need to look at this ruling very closely,” he said.

Comments - 2 Responses

  1. Geoffrey Smith says:

    So now Catholics are being forced out of another profession. First it was that of registrars. Then it was illegal to operate a boarding house that discriminated against gays. Now it’s the profession of midwifery, since Catholics will have no truck with abortion. Eventually there will be no place for us in this country, the country of our birth, and we may as well leave it and go and live in Arabia. We are virtually dhimmis in Britain, so life in Arabia could hardly be worse than it is here in this God-forsaken UK.

  2. GABY says:

    So nice of the judge to decide for the plaintiffs what are appropriate limits for their conscience. But then, it’s hardly THEIR conscience that’s being protected, is it?
    Is it true that the European Convention on Human Rights doesn’t hold “freedom of conscience and religion to be absolute”?

Leave a Reply

latest news

Papal Way of the Cross mediations on financial crises and social justice

April 15th, 2014 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

The Holy Father’s Good Friday address, written by an archbishop...


Pope gives prisoners gift of pocket Gospels

April 15th, 2014 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

The Holy Father is to send a special Easter gift...


Who are we before Jesus who suffers?

April 14th, 2014 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

Pope Francis tells Palm Sunday congregation that the characters in...


United Nations told not to treat pregnancy as a disease

April 11th, 2014 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

Holy See’s Permanent Observer advises care for the poor, rather...




Social media

Latest edition

PAGE-1-APR-18-2014

exclusively in the paper

  • SCO exclusive: Bishop John Keenan on Blessed John Paul II and the Theology of the Body ahead of Papal Canonisations.
  • Pope Francis promises stronger action on clerical abuse, feels responsible.
  • Redemptorist Fr James Crampsey examines justice, compassion, wisdom and intergity.
  • Daniel Harkins offers an insight into the Taize community, with a focus on its recent event in Edinburgh.
  • SCO exclusive: James Barclay’s Easter short story.

Previous editions

Previous editions of the Scottish Catholic Observer newspaper are only available to subscribed Members. To download previous editions of the paper, please subscribe.

note: registered members only.

Read the SCO