BY Ian Dunn | January 20 2012 | comments icon 2 COMMENTS     print icon print

1-CARDINAL-&-ALEX-SALMOND

Is there Faith in independence?

— Scottish Church has ecclesiastical independence but questions remain for Catholics over country’s future

The Scottish Government’s plans to hold referendum in 2014 on independence have sharply divided opinion among leading Scots Catholics.

An exclusive SCO survey of many of the foremost Catholic voices in Scotland found that, while most agreed it was a matter for the Scottish people to decide, there were underlying concerns that an independent Scotland could be even more hostile to Catholics than the status quo of the union.

Ecclesiastical independence

Last week’s announcement by First Minister Alex Salmond that he intended to hold the referendum in the autumn of 2014, and that a detailed consultation document on the arrangements would be published on January 25, was met with a hostile reaction from Prime Minster David Cameron and other unionist politicians, who insisted any vote should be held within 18 months.

The official position of the Bishops’ Conference of Scotland, expressed by Bishop Philip Tartaglia of Paisley, is that ‘the constitutional question is a matter solely for the people of Scotland to decide.’

However, both Bishop Tartaglia and Cardinal Keith O’Brien agreed that the existing independence of the Scottish Church showed broader independence for Scotland was a viable idea.

“It is true that the Catholic Church in Scotland has a distinct and internationally recognised position,” Cardinal O’Brien said. “So it would be difficult to argue that ecclesiastical independence is acceptable but political independence is not.”

The cardinal also said he believed that the independence movement in Scotland was fuelled by ‘frustration among the Scots about the say they have over what happens here.’

Catholic schools

On the crucial issue of Catholic education, Michael McGrath, the director of the Scottish Catholic Education Service, said it was ‘unlikely’ independence would have a ‘dramatic impact’ in the ‘short term.’

Mr McGrath highlighted it was possible that independence could lead to lessening of the ‘sectarian attitudes which still prevail amongst some.’ However, he also expressed underlying fears that it could lead to ‘greater insularity amongst Scots, some of whom have traditionally held hostile attitudes towards Catholic education,’ adding that he was wary of ‘this issue distracting politicians from the major economic challenges faced by all of us for some years to come.’

Political reaction

Michael McMahon, the Scottish Labour MSP for Uddingston and Bellshill, expressed similar concerns to Mr McGrath.

“While Scotland is by no means too small or too poor to survive as a separate state, turning our neighbours into foreigners and our industrial partners into our main economic competitors will diminish us and do nothing to enhance Scotland’s position in the world, or the Catholic community’s position within Scotland,” Mr McMahon said.

Former nationalist candidate and SCO columnist David Kerr provided a riposte to that view. “As part of the United Kingdom our voice has never been listened to by London’s political elite at Westminster on a whole host of key ethical issues, abortion, stem cell research, gay adoption, nuclear weapons, the Act of Settlement, the list goes on and on,” he said. “As Blessed Pope John Paul II proclaimed 30 years ago at Bellahouston—‘Let Scotland flourish.’ That is something best achieved with independence.”

Underlying problems

Professor Emeritus Patrick Reilly of Glasgow University issued a profound warning that the independence debate could obscure serious problems in Scottish society, such as the ill treatment of Christians, in particular Catholics.

“Today, the Catholic Church now speaks for many Christian denominations on our shores,” he said. “We were once ill treated and marginalised for our Catholic Faith, we are now treated this way for being Christians. However, given the current mood in our country, nothing has changed to make me more confident that Catholics would fare any better in an independent Scotland.”

— Read full reactions to independence in this week’s edition of The Scottish Catholic Observer

[email protected]

Comments - 2 Responses

  1. archie birt says:

    It is appropriate that the SCO should report and comment on political matters but I would urge that Mother Church keeps well clear of the politicians and the political class generally – if ye sup wi’ the Deil yase a lang spoon has to be the approach – what one set of politicians give another set can take away. Catholics in the Scottish electorate have to make up their own minds as to which way to vote in Mr Salmond’s referendum and no doubt your columns will be available to this purpose.

  2. Michael Dolan says:

    Dear Archie,

    At the risk of sounding a creep, I would say that rather than tell Catholics how they should vote, what has been done by a range of commentators is to provide, in a brief yet comprehensive form, an outline of some of the main issues to be considered.

    My only reservation is that it would haven been nice to see a photograph of what Joseph Bradley looks like, as he has commented on a number of serious issues in the ‘ Scottish Catholic Observer ‘.

Leave a Reply

previous lead stories

Neocatechumenal Way gives joyful witness of Faith

September 5th, 2014 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

More than 800 people, including 160 foreign pilgrims, packed into...


Double your SCIAF support

August 29th, 2014 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

The Scottish Catholic International Aid Fund has won UK Government...


Pope Francis hopes for ‘few more years’

August 22nd, 2014 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

Pontiff gives revealing interview on trip from South Korea on...


‘These are our own flesh and blood’

August 15th, 2014 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

Bishop Gilbert, Pope Francis make impassioned pleas for help for...




Social media

Latest edition

P1-SEPT-5-2014

exclusively in the paper

  • Extended report on Scotland’s archbishops urging prayer for, and participation in, the referendum
  • The Italian government takes the terrorist threat on Pope Francis’ life seriously.
  • New ordained permanent deacon Len Moir tells the story of his journey of Faith.
  • Young Mum catherine MacMillan’s moving personal account of having a severely disabled daughter.
  • Opinions: Sr Roseann Reddy takes a stand on independence; Hugh Dougherty on motherhood and Scotland and Michael McGrath says children must be taught that God has a loving plan for them.

Previous editions

Previous editions of the Scottish Catholic Observer newspaper are only available to subscribed Members. To download previous editions of the paper, please subscribe.

note: registered members only.

Read the SCO