BY Ian Dunn | March 12 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS     print icon print


Euthanasia case to proceed

High Court judge allows locked-in syndrome sufferer Tony Nicklinson’s case for a doctor to legally kill him to be heard even though assisted suicide and euthanasia are against UK law

A severely disabled man who wants a doctor to be able to lawfully kill him can proceed with his court case, a judge ruled today in spite of deeming part the case an issue for Parliament.

The High Court in London ruled that Tony Nicklinson (above), 57, who is paralysed from the neck down but whose mental faculties are unaffected, can continue his legal fight to ensure that any doctor who would kill him would be spared murder charges.

The Ministry of Justice had wanted the case to be struck out, arguing that only Parliament can change the law on murder. Judge William Charles ruled against only one part of Mr Nicklinson’s claim, allowing him to proceed with his action. The judge said Mr Nicklinson, who suffers from locked-in syndrome following a stroke in 2005, did not have a realistic chance of persuading a court to declare that ‘existing domestic law and practice fail adequately to regulate the practice of active euthanasia.’

“The reason for this is that the court should not engage in that debate because it is a matter for Parliament,” the judge said, adding that the rest of the case could proceed.

Mr Nicklinson from Wiltshire in south-west England, who communicates by controlling a computer with eye movements, has described his life as ‘dull, miserable, demeaning, undignified and intolerable.’

A spokesman for Care not Killing said today’s ruling was a very worrying development.

“No one can help but be sympathetic to Tony Nicklinson but cases like his are extremely rare and hard cases make bad law,” he said. “The overwhelming majority of people with severe disability do not wish to die but rather want support to live.

“The current law is clear and right and does not need fixing or further weakening. On the one hand the penalties it holds in reserve act as a powerful deterrent to exploitation and abuse by those who might have an interest, financial or otherwise, in the deaths of vulnerable people. On the other hand the law gives judges some discretion to temper justice with mercy when sentencing in hard cases. We should not be meddling with it.”

The Catholic Church in Scotland has repeatedly spoken out against assisted suicide and euthanasia, prompted in recent years by independent MSP Margo MacDonald’s attempts to have them legalised by the Scottish Parliament.

Leave a Reply

latest news

Local authority and Catholic priests resolve transport dispute

September 13th, 2019 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

A dispute between Catholic parents and a local authority has...

Prayers and hope for Margaret Sinclair’s sainthood cause at annual pilgrimage

September 13th, 2019 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

As Margaret Sinclair’s sainthood cause drew nearer at St Patrick’s...

St Andrews and Edinburgh celebrates bumper weekend for vocations at cathedral

September 13th, 2019 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

A deacon and a permanent deacon were ordained at St...

Woman with cancer reveals her ‘very special’ encounter with the relics of St Therese

September 6th, 2019 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

Despite undergoing radiotherapy five days a week, Jane joined her...

Social media

Latest edition

Screen Shot 2019-09-12 at 11.02.33

exclusively in the paper

  • Exclusive coverage of the tour of the Little Flower’s relics
  • Marches could be limited by law after disorder, justice secretary says
  • Catholics hear urgent call on climate change
  • Teaching union calls for health screening at St Ambrose High School
  • The priest looking for signs of alien life, by Carol Glatz

Previous editions

Previous editions of the Scottish Catholic Observer newspaper are only available to subscribed Members. To download previous editions of the paper, please subscribe.

note: registered members only.

Read the SCO