BY Ian Dunn | May 13 2011 | comments icon 2 COMMENTS     print icon print


Schools face ‘bigoted’ attack

— Bishop Devine leads dismissal of legal group’s claim Catholic education causes sectarianism

Leading Scottish Catholics have united in their condemnation of an extreme attack on Catholic schools that purported their abolition was the only way of ‘confronting and counteracting sectarianism’ in Scotland.

Senior Catholic clergy, lawyers and educationalists have resoundingly dismissed the Scottish Legal Action Group’s call for an end to Catholic state education on these grounds.

Bishop Joseph Devine of Motherwell told the SCO that the editorial in the Scolag journal was a ‘malicious proposal’ and nothing short of an ‘outrageous attack on the freedom and democratic principles of our country.’

Sectarian attack

Bishop Devine, the member of the Bishops’ Conference of Scotland with responsibility for education, went on to say that he believed that sectarianism itself was behind attacks on Catholic schools.

“The blunt truth is that sectarianism fuels the continuous attack on Catholic education in Scotland,” he said. “The real enemy of all religious people is secularism which breeds sectarianism and those who espouse it and propagate it are Christianity’s greatest foes.

“I challenge these groups to produce the hard evidence to support their irresponsible claims or withdraw them. Around 130,000 young people—just over 20 per cent of the school population—are taught in 369 Catholic schools across Scotland. It would appear that the greater the achievements of [our] Catholic schools… the greater the hysteria grows for their abolition.”

Political support

Bishop Devine pointed out that both Prime Minster David Cameron and First Minister Alex Salmond have been wholehearted in their praise of Catholic schools.

“The Prime Minister believes that faith schools should be seen as the model for all state schools to follow, while Scotland’s First Minister urges us to celebrate our distinguished achievements,” he said.

All the major political parties contesting the Scottish parliamentary election on May 5 told the SCO that they would continue the current set up of Catholic state education.

“Most important of all, of course, is the fact that over 95 per cent of Catholic parents freely choose to have their children educated in Catholic schools,” the bishop added.

He also said that in many Catholic schools a substantial percentage of the school roll consists of children who are not Catholic, something he said was ‘a clear demonstration by their parents of their recognition of the value of Catholic schools in providing their children with an excellent academic, spiritual and well-rounded education.’

Expert opinion

Michael McGrath, director of the Scottish Catholic Education Service, said he believed that Scolag was opining on a subject about which it was not knowledgeable.

“To say this is entirely out with the parameters of its expertise would be fair,” he said. “It is interesting and disappointing, that a supposedly informed journal would come to such a conclusion.

“If they consult the facts and the evidence I think they would have to withdraw their assertions. If they are so willing to ignore the reality of the situation it’s hard not to come to the conclusion that their assertions are based in prejudice.”

Legal argument

Maurice Jamieson, a Glasgow-based Catholic advocate, said he was baffled at the conclusion the piece had arrived at.

“Looking at the editorial, there is no evidence to support their conclusion and, as a lawyer, I find that concerning,” he said. “It also seems to suggest taking away the right of Catholics to send their children to Catholic schools, a right which is enshrined in law. And the assumption seems to be that taking that right away will somehow create a solution to these problems without conceding that this would be penalising people of faith.

“Taking that to its conclusion ‘pluralist secularism’ solves a problem by denying rights of one group in society when apparently it’s all of society’s problem. That is discriminatory and inconsistent with tolerance, a key component of a mature and confident liberal democracy.”

Peter Kearney, of the Catholic media office, also condemned the article outright, saying ‘the Scolag editorial’s analysis of sectarianism in Scotland is so fatuous that it really doesn’t merit a response.’

He did, however, speak of the legal implications. “These comments on Catholic schools, though published in an obscure and arcane journal, still constitute an ill informed and unprovoked attack on religious freedom,” he said. “The European Convention on Human Rights enshrines the right of parents to have their children educated in accordance with their beliefs.”


The editorial in the May edition of the Scolag journal was written in response to the recent media furore over sectarianism that has seen parcel bombs sent to high profile Catholics.

The article attacking Scotland’s Catholic schools is perceived as an extreme view at the fringes of society.

“The Scottish Parliament has expressly legislated to make religious discrimination an aggravation to a criminal offence,” it says. “But the degree to which such legal measures can counteract sectarianism is questionable and even doubtful when in other regards our law and civic bodies continue to enshrine, protect and systematically promote social division on religious lines.

“That is done most widely and effectively in our education system where the maintenance of religious instruction and observance, along with the public funding of denominational schools create and perpetuate religious discrimination.”

The editorial also claims its call would serve ‘an even wider purpose, confronting and counteracting sectarianism as well as exclusion and discrimination in other forms if, at long last, a clear division was established in Scotland between church and State by ending religious instruction and denominational schools.’


Comments - 2 Responses

  1. Chris Williams says:

    In response I would like to quote Bishop Devine

    “I challenge these groups to produce the hard evidence to support their irresponsible claims or withdraw them” however it is evidence supporting Bishop Devines offensive a accusation that “We now have a straight fight between faith and atheism, morality and amorality, a culture of life and a culture of death”… how can any sane person say that atheists are amoral

  2. joe green says:

    you scots really make me laugh. catholics have for generations been the subject of discrimination and bigotry in your country. you are notorious for this and the whole world knows about it too. you now want to restrict catholics from having a catholic education because this allegedly is the real cause of the problem. methinks that a little introspection and honesty is required here. first of all an apology to catholics is needed for the hundreds of years of bigotry that has been visited upon them. secondly real laws aimed at this particular type of discrimination is what is required not further bigoted attempts to suppress catholic education done under the guise of anti-sectarianism. what is even more appalling is that such proposals contravene the european convention of rights. in any normal society a group such as the scottish legal action group would be hauled before the courts and charged criminally for proposing the imposition of further sectarian restrictions against catholics.

Leave a Reply

previous lead stories

Scottish Government criticised over abortion funding after poll shows opposition

February 23rd, 2018 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

Church criticises Holyrood for funding abortions for women from Northern...

Secular fundamentalists are ‘denying Christians a voice’

February 16th, 2018 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

Church’s parliament representative criticises ‘new secular religion with a fundamentalist...

Don’t forget Christians in the Holy Land, bishop urges

February 9th, 2018 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

Bishop William Nolan calls for more Scottish pilgrimages to the...

Don’t be afraid to talk to the homeless, Catholics urged

February 2nd, 2018 | comments icon 0 COMMENTS

Scottish Church’s social justice group criticises crisis driven by ‘austerity’...

Social media

Latest edition


exclusively in the paper

  • Exclusive extract from Jordan Peterson’s book on Christianity and ignorant atheism
  • The tale of the young mother who won Scottish Schools’ young writer of the year
  • Churches unite to aid refugee boy who lost his mother
  • Parents call for boys to be admitted to all girls school

Previous editions

Previous editions of the Scottish Catholic Observer newspaper are only available to subscribed Members. To download previous editions of the paper, please subscribe.

note: registered members only.

Read the SCO